Payments Make a Payment You can easily make a payment online or by phone. Choose the company below to get started. Make a Claim AFR Insurance (800) 324-7771Pay Online American Modern (800) 543-2644 Pay Online Amerisafe (800) 897-9719Pay Online CNA Insurance Company Pay by phone:(877) 276-7507 Compsource Mutual Insurance Company (800) 347-3863Pay Online Encompass (866) 430-2916Pay Online Foremost Insurance Company (888) 888-0080Pay Online Hanover (800) 573-1187Pay Online The Hartford (860) 547-5000Pay Online Liberty Mutual Insurance (888) 398-8924Pay Online Main Street America Group (877) 927-5672Pay Online Mercury Insurance Group (888)-637-2176Pay Online MetLife Auto and Home (800) 680-3354Pay Online National American Insurance Company Pay by phone:(405) 258-0804 North Star Mutual (800) 622-5230Pay Online Philadelphia Insurance Company (877) 438-7459Pay Online Progressive (855) 758-0943Pay Online Safeco Insurance Company (800) 332-3226Pay Online Travelers (800) 842-5075Pay Online
