Payments Make a Claim You can easily make a claim online or by phone. Choose the company below to get started. Make a Payment AFR Insurance (800) 324-7771 Report a Claim American Modern (800) 375-2075 Report Claim Amerisafe (800) 699-6240 Report Claim CNA Insurance Company (877) 262-2727 Report Claim Compsource Mutual Insurance Company (800) 347-3863 Claims ext. 3872 Report Claim Encompass (866) 430-2916 Report Claim Foremost Insurance Company Personal (800) 527-3907 Business (800) 435-7764 Report Claim Hanover (800) 799-6977 Report Claim The Hartford (800) 243-5860Report Claim Liberty Mutual Insurance (800) 225-2467Report Claim Main Street America Group (877) 425-2467 Report Claim Mercury Insurance Group (800) 503-3724 Report Claim MetLife Auto and Home (800) 854-6011 Report Claim National American Insurance Company (405) 258-0804 Report Claim North Star Mutual (800) 622-5230 Report Claim Philadelphia Insurance Company (800) 765-9749 Report Claim Progressive (855) 347-3939 Report Claim Safeco Insurance Company (800) 332-3226 Report Claim Travelers (800) 252-4633 Report Claim
